Moving to Shopify Plus from Adobe Commerce (Magento) or Salesforce Commerce Cloud

Most merchants who leave Adobe Commerce (Magento) or Salesforce Commerce Cloud for Shopify Plus do it to cut what they spend keeping the site running: license fees, hosting, and developer hours on patches and upgrades. One brand I led through the move cut its total cost of ownership in half.

The move pays off when it's scoped well. It goes wrong when integrations, data and SEO get treated as details for later. This page covers what the move costs, what goes wrong, and what to settle before you sign with an agency.

By Bret Williams, author of Mastering Magento, Mastering Magento 2 and Learning Magento 2 Administration. Last updated November 2026.

Why merchants leave Adobe Commerce (Magento) and SFCC

  • Total cost of ownership. License, hosting and a steady stream of developer hours for security patches and version upgrades.

  • Upgrades that become projects. A major Adobe Commerce (Magento) upgrade can cost as much as a small rebuild.

  • Developer dependence. Simple changes wait on a specialist developer or agency, and good Adobe Commerce (Magento) developers are harder to find each year.

  • Speed. Merchandising and marketing teams want to launch pages, promotions and markets without a ticket.

Where migrations go wrong

  • Integrations scoped last. ERP, OMS, PIM, tax and fulfillment connections are usually the hardest part, and the part bids are vaguest about.

  • Custom checkout and pricing logic. Rules that lived in Adobe Commerce (Magento) code have to be rebuilt with Shopify Functions, apps or a different process. Someone has to list them all first.

  • Data. Products, customers, orders and content rarely map one-to-one. Customer passwords can't be moved, so you need a plan for account activation.

  • Search rankings. Every old URL needs a redirect, and every language version needs the right tags.

  • International. Store views and websites in Adobe Commerce (Magento) don't map directly to Shopify Markets and expansion stores. The structure you pick shapes your costs for years.

What to settle before you sign with an agency

  1. A written list of everything your current site does, including the things nobody remembers building.

  2. An integration map, with who owns each system.

  3. A decision on store and market structure if you sell in more than one country.

  4. A budget range you've checked against more than one estimate.

  5. A launch plan that avoids your peak season.

This is what my readiness plan produces. Book a 30-minute call and I'll tell you which of these you already have.

Book an intro call

Common questions

Planning a move to Shopify Plus?

Book a 30-minute call. I'll tell you what to settle before you sign with an agency.

Book an intro call